1. Home
  2. /
  3. Projects /
  4. Holiday & Seasonal Crafts
  5. / Monster Eyeball Cookies
Time Required :
Over an hour
Beginner
Beginner
You're new to the skills necessary to complete this project, or maybe you've tried them just once or twice before.

monster eyeball cookies

Keep your eyes peeled for these monster cookie treats.
Share your project photos with #MakeItWithMichaels

Print Project

Step 1
Quantities Needed for This Project:
½ cup Butter, Softened
½ tsp. Vanilla
1 8 oz. Cream Cheese Bar, Softened
1 Egg
1 Box Cake Mix – White
Powdered Sugar
Chocolate Covered Candy
 
Beat butter, vanilla, egg and cream cheese until light and fluffy. Mix in cake mix. Place half of the batter into a separate bowl. Tint one bowl of batter bright pink. Add green and yellow food coloring to the batter in the second bowl. Mix both until completely blended. Chill batters for 30 minutes. 
Step 2
Line cookie sheet with parchment paper. Pre-heat oven to 350°. 
Step 3
Roll cookie dough into loose balls and dip into powdered sugar. 
Step 4
Place on cookie sheet about 2" apart and pat down a bit. Bake at 350° for 10-12 minutes. Add candy. 
Step 5
Share your project photos with #MadeWithMichaels 
Supplies
Materials
Materials
 
  • img
    You’ll Need: 1

    Wilton® Parchment Paper

    Item # 10076247 
    Save 20% with code 20MADEBYYOU See Details See Details
    Valid Online. EXCLUSIONS: Great Buy items; clearance; doorbusters; MichaelsPro Packs; custom framing; beverages & candy; books & magazines; gift cards; LEGO; sewing machines; craft technology & accessories; Cricut, Silhouette; Christmas trees. Exclusions subject to change.
    $6.49
  • img
    953005939
    You’ll Need: 1

    Wilton® Icing Color

    Item # 10051374 
    Save 20% with code 20MADEBYYOU See Details See Details
    Valid Online. EXCLUSIONS: Great Buy items; clearance; doorbusters; MichaelsPro Packs; custom framing; beverages & candy; books & magazines; gift cards; LEGO; sewing machines; craft technology & accessories; Cricut, Silhouette; Christmas trees. Exclusions subject to change.
    $2.39
    • Color: Kelly Green
    • Size: 1 oz
    • Color: Kelly Green
    • Size: 1 oz
    +More Colors
    • Color: Kelly Green
    • Size: 1 oz
    +More Colors
    +More Options
  • img
    953005939
    You’ll Need: 1

    Wilton® Icing Color

    Item # 10123678 
    Save 20% with code 20MADEBYYOU See Details See Details
    Valid Online. EXCLUSIONS: Great Buy items; clearance; doorbusters; MichaelsPro Packs; custom framing; beverages & candy; books & magazines; gift cards; LEGO; sewing machines; craft technology & accessories; Cricut, Silhouette; Christmas trees. Exclusions subject to change.
    $2.39
    • Color: Rose
    • Size: 1 oz
    • Color: Rose
    • Size: 1 oz
    +More Colors
    • Color: Rose
    • Size: 1 oz
    +More Colors
    +More Options
  • img
    953005939
    You’ll Need: 1

    Wilton® Icing Color

    Item # 10051377 
    Save 20% with code 20MADEBYYOU See Details See Details
    Valid Online. EXCLUSIONS: Great Buy items; clearance; doorbusters; MichaelsPro Packs; custom framing; beverages & candy; books & magazines; gift cards; LEGO; sewing machines; craft technology & accessories; Cricut, Silhouette; Christmas trees. Exclusions subject to change.
    $2.39
    • Color: Lemon Yellow
    • Size: 1 oz
    • Color: Lemon Yellow
    • Size: 1 oz
    +More Colors
    • Color: Lemon Yellow
    • Size: 1 oz
    +More Colors
    +More Options
 
 
 
You’ll Also Need
  • Mixing Bowls
  • Powdered Sugar
  • Spatula
  • Electric Mixer
  • Egg
  • Vanilla
  • Cake Mix – White
  • Chocolate Covered Candy
  • Cookie Sheet
  • Wilton® Candy Eyeballs, Large (sku 10265792)
  • Butter, Softened
  • Cream Cheese Bar, Softened
Instructions
Step 1
Quantities Needed for This Project:
½ cup Butter, Softened
½ tsp. Vanilla
1 8 oz. Cream Cheese Bar, Softened
1 Egg
1 Box Cake Mix – White
Powdered Sugar
Chocolate Covered Candy
 
Beat butter, vanilla, egg and cream cheese until light and fluffy. Mix in cake mix. Place half of the batter into a separate bowl. Tint one bowl of batter bright pink. Add green and yellow food coloring to the batter in the second bowl. Mix both until completely blended. Chill batters for 30 minutes. 
Step 2
Line cookie sheet with parchment paper. Pre-heat oven to 350°. 
Step 3
Roll cookie dough into loose balls and dip into powdered sugar. 
Step 4
Place on cookie sheet about 2" apart and pat down a bit. Bake at 350° for 10-12 minutes. Add candy. 
Step 5
Share your project photos with #MadeWithMichaels 
Project Reviews