15 Personalized and Unique Gifts For People Who Have Everything

Finding the perfect present is never easy, especially when you're shopping for someone who seems to already have it all. That’s where the magic of personalized, handcrafted gifts comes in. Whether you're looking for something heartfelt, humorous, or entirely one-of-a-kind, MakerPlace by Michaels has you covered with artisan-made items you won’t find anywhere else.

In this guide, you’ll find gift ideas for men, women and those truly hard-to-buy-for friends and family members. Scroll on for curated picks from our talented maker community, each designed to wow even the toughest recipients on your list.

5 presents for people with everything

When they say "don’t get me anything," these unexpected, delightful picks are sure to change their mind. Think thoughtful details, customizable touches, and items they never knew they needed—but now won’t want to live without.

1. Custom Front Door Portrait

Looking for a housewarming gift for someone who has all their household essentials? Capture the charm of your loved one’s home with this custom front door portrait. This is a heartfelt keepsake that they'll treasure for years to come. Digitally painted by an independent artist on MakerPlace, each piece is personalized to reflect the unique details of the chosen front door. Thoughtful, original and beautifully crafted, it’s a gift that feels truly special. Shop this or find similar custom art pieces in our huge range at MakerPlace.

2. Smiling Planter with Dangling Legs

Brighten someone’s day with this unique planter. A quirky, cheerful gift that’s perfect for the person who has everything. With rope legs, mini skates, and an adorable expression, this handmade planter adds charm to any shelf or windowsill. It’s a fun, functional piece that’s ideal for succulents and guaranteed to spark joy. Looking for something else for the plant lover in your life? Look no further! Browse our wide collection of outdoor and indoor gardening supplies.

3. Personalized Charcuterie Board Set

Elevate their hosting game with this Round Personalized Charcuterie Board Set. A standout gift for the person who already has all the basic kitchen and dining supplies they could need! This 19-piece set includes a custom-engraved board and matching knives, blending elegance with function. Perfect for weddings, housewarmings or holiday gatherings, it's a timeless piece they'll reach for again and again.

4. Book Lover Candle

Delight the bookworm who has everything with this Oxford Wizard Library Literary Candle that will add to any reading nook’s vibe. This is a handmade soy candle inspired by magical reading rooms and old-world charm. With rich, bookish scents and a cozy glow, it’s perfect for curling up with a favorite novel. Thoughtfully crafted and beautifully packaged, all our candle options are thoughtful gifts.

5. Crochet Small Pet Bed/Tunnel

Shopping for someone who has everything? Why not get something for their pet instead? This Crochet Guinea Pig Bed and Tunnel is the ultimate cozy hideaway for small pets like guinea pigs, hamsters or rats. Handmade and customizable with soft fleece and adorable detail, it’s both a comfy retreat and a playful tunnel. A thoughtful, unexpected gift for pet lovers who treat their fur babies like family.

5 gifts for men who have everything

Shopping for dads, brothers, partners, or friends who claim they don’t need a thing? These artisan-made finds mix practicality with personality—perfect for the guy who appreciates quality and originality.

1. Personalized Hammer

Looking for a meaningful gift for the man who has everything? This personalized engraved hammer is both practical and sentimental - perfect for the DIY dads, grandpas, or any handyman with a heart. Custom engraving options like “Best Dad Ever” or heartfelt messages turn a classic tool into a keepsake he’ll treasure with every project.

2. Personalized Grill Set

The man who has everything probably doesn’t have this. This personalized grill set is the ultimate gift for BBQ lovers. Complete with custom-engraved tools that add a personal touch to every cookout, this set turns grilling into a proud display of craftsmanship. At MakerPlace, we have a wide range of grill accessories to help you find exactly what you’re looking for!

3. Custom Golf Balls

For the grandpa who’s a golf pro at heart, this Custom "Best Grandpa by Par" Golf Ball Set is a hole-in-one gift he won’t see coming. Personalized and printed on quality Pinnacle Soft golf balls, it’s a fun, thoughtful way to celebrate Father’s Day, retirement, or any special occasion. Check out our other golf gifts to celebrate the golfer in your life.

4. Custom Whiskey Glasses

When socks and ties just won’t cut it, go for something truly refined. These custom whiskey glasses with an engraved box are a sophisticated, personalized gift set he’ll actually want to use. Ideal for Father’s Day, birthdays or just because, this handcrafted set adds a touch of class to his favorite pour. Shop our full drink and barware range for even more customizable options.

5. Funny Workout Gym T-Shirt

Got a guy who lives in the gym and already owns every gadget? This “Loading Weights Is My Cardio” T-Shirt is the perfect blend of fitness and humor. Made for men who lift (and love a good laugh), it’s a fun, wearable gift that shows you get his lifestyle. Comfortable, durable, and definitely attention-grabbing, this tee brings personality to every workout. Explore our full collection of men's t-shirts for more options to fit any hobby.

5 gifts for women who have everything

From luxurious self-care to statement-making accessories, these handcrafted gifts are ideal for women who love thoughtful, original items made just for them.

1. Spa Gift Set

When she says she doesn’t need anything, this NEVAEH Spa Gift Set proves otherwise. Filled with handmade, all-natural self-care essentials and customizable with your choice of bath bombs, this beautifully curated set is perfect for birthdays, housewarmings or just because. It’s thoughtful, indulgent and refreshingly unique. At MakerPlace, we have a wide range of bath and spa accessories to choose from, helping your loved one unwind and truly relax.

2. Personalized Tote Bag

Stylish, practical and personal, this personalized initial and name canvas tote bag is the kind of everyday essential that feels like a treat. Whether she’s heading to the market, gym, or weekend getaway, this custom monogrammed tote adds a chic, meaningful touch to her routine. It’s a perfect gift for birthdays, bridesmaids, or just to show you care. Looking for a different type of bag or purse? MakerPlace has you covered!

3. Bubble Letter Name Necklace

Looking for something as bold and personal as she is? This popular bubble letter name necklace is a playful, eye-catching piece of custom jewelry she’ll actually want to wear. Whether you choose her name, initials or a meaningful word, this 3D necklace makes a stylish, statement-making gift for new moms, bridesmaids, or trendsetters who have it all. Not quite her style? We have a vast collection of customizable jewelry and other monogrammed name necklaces to match her unique vibe.

4. Handprint Sign

She may say she doesn’t want anything, but this custom handprint sign will melt her heart. Featuring your child’s actual handprints and a sweet “Best Mom Ever, Hands Down” message, it’s a deeply personal keepsake she’ll treasure forever. Perfect for Mother’s Day or just because, it’s a reminder of the little hands that hold her world. Shopping for a pet mom? No problem - just use pawprints instead!

5. Embroidery Kit

For the creative spirit who seems to have it all, this flower garden embroidery kit is a heartfelt, hands-on gift she’ll truly appreciate. With beginner-friendly materials and a design that lets her represent each family member as a flower, it’s both a relaxing project and a meaningful keepsake she’ll be proud to display. Explore our embroidery section for even more choice.

Still stumped on what to buy for someone who has everything? The answer isn’t more stuff, it’s something meaningful. At MakerPlace by Michaels, every gift is handmade, heartfelt, and one-of-a-kind. Whether you’re celebrating a milestone, showing appreciation, or just making someone smile, these personalized finds are proof that the best gifts come with a story. Explore our gift guide to find more handcrafted treasures from independent makers and turn your next gift into something unforgettable. If you still can’t find the perfect gift, why not surprise them with an experience or celebration instead? Whether it’s a low-key gathering or a full-blown celebration, our party supplies make it easy to turn any moment into a memory.