Michaels

MakerPlace

Custom Framing

Michaels Rewards

Gift Cards

Classes & Events

Projects

Weekly Ad

Coupons

Logo Home
loading
loading

Home

/

Holidays & Occasions

/

Halloween

/

Halloween Baking & Party

/

Halloween Baking

Pickup & Delivery
Indoor/Outdoor
Brand
Sales & Offers
Color

Orange (38)

Multi

Multi (31)

Black (20)

White (19)

Silver (11)

Size
Price
Ratings

Please choose a rating

How would you like to get it?

Halloween Baking

125 Results

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Meltables™
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Meltables™
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Meltables™
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Meltables™
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Meltables™

+ 11

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Meltables™

$3.99

Reg.$4.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Eat, Drink & Be Scary Sprinkle Mix
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Eat, Drink & Be Scary Sprinkle Mix

$2.49

Reg.$4.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Melting Pot Cauldron with Forks by American Crafts™
Melting Pot Cauldron with Forks by American Crafts™

$24.99

Reg.$49.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Black Fairy Sparkle Edible Glitter
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Black Fairy Sparkle Edible Glitter

$6.49

Reg.$12.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Green Fairy Sparkle Edible Glitter
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Green Fairy Sparkle Edible Glitter

$6.49

Reg.$12.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Sore Eyes Sprinkle Mix
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Sore Eyes Sprinkle Mix

$2.49

Reg.$4.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Satin Ice® White Buttercream Frosting, 1lb.
Satin Ice® White Buttercream Frosting, 1lb.

$6.99

20% off Every Regular Price Purchase with Code FALL20OFF Online only

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Brains Gummy Toppers
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Brains Gummy Toppers

$4.49

Reg.$8.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

3D Ghost Silicone Treat Mold by Celebrate It®
3D Ghost Silicone Treat Mold by Celebrate It®

$6.49

Reg.$12.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Creep & Crawl Sprinkle Mix
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Creep & Crawl Sprinkle Mix

$2.49

Reg.$4.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Spiders Gummy Toppers
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Spiders Gummy Toppers

$4.49

Reg.$8.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Create-A-Treat™ OREO DIY Halloween Cookie Kit
Create-A-Treat™ OREO DIY Halloween Cookie Kit

$9.99

Reg.$19.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Trick or Treat Baking Cups, 24ct. by Celebrate It®
Trick or Treat Baking Cups, 24ct. by Celebrate It®

$1.99

Reg.$3.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Witches Night Out Sprinkle Mix
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Witches Night Out Sprinkle Mix

$2.49

Reg.$4.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Create-A-Treat® OREO® Spooky Castle Cookie Kit
Create-A-Treat® OREO® Spooky Castle Cookie Kit

$9.99

Reg.$19.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Ectoplasm Glow Drink Mix
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Ectoplasm Glow Drink Mix

$2.99

Reg.$5.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Broom Rider Sprinkle Mix
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Broom Rider Sprinkle Mix

$6.49

Reg.$12.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Ghost, Skeleton & Bat Treat Toppers, 12ct. by Celebrate It®
Ghost, Skeleton & Bat Treat Toppers, 12ct. by Celebrate It®

$1.49

Reg.$2.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Monster Eyes Baking Cups, 24ct. by Celebrate It®
Monster Eyes Baking Cups, 24ct. by Celebrate It®

$1.99

Reg.$3.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

7" Skull Stainless Steel Tongs by Celebrate It®
7" Skull Stainless Steel Tongs by Celebrate It®

$3.49

Reg.$6.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Nightmare Rimming Sugar
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Nightmare Rimming Sugar

$3.99

Reg.$7.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Yum Crumbs 6oz. Sugar Cookie Dessert Toppings
Yum Crumbs 6oz. Sugar Cookie Dessert Toppings

$3.99

Reg.$7.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Spider Cupcake Baking Set by Celebrate It®
Spider Cupcake Baking Set by Celebrate It®

$4.99

Reg.$9.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Green Apple Witch's Brew Glow Drink Mix
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Green Apple Witch's Brew Glow Drink Mix

$2.99

Reg.$5.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Tricks & Treats Sprinkle Mix
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Tricks & Treats Sprinkle Mix

$6.49

Reg.$12.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Fairy Sparkle Orange Edible Glitter
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Fairy Sparkle Orange Edible Glitter

$6.49

Reg.$12.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

2-in-1 Halloween Treat Carrier by Celebrate It®
2-in-1 Halloween Treat Carrier by Celebrate It®

$9.99

Reg.$19.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Vampire Teeth Cupcake Rings, 12ct. by Celebrate It®
Vampire Teeth Cupcake Rings, 12ct. by Celebrate It®

$1.99

Reg.$3.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

9" Ghost Zipper Treat Bags with Handles, 12ct. by Celebrate It®
9" Ghost Zipper Treat Bags with Handles, 12ct. by Celebrate It®

$1.99

Reg.$3.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code

Sweet Tooth Fairy® Purple Fairy Sparkle Edible Glitter
Sweet Tooth Fairy® Purple Fairy Sparkle Edible Glitter

$6.49

Reg.$12.99

Store Pickup

-

Unavailable

Ship to Me

-

Unavailable

Same Day Delivery

-

New ZIP Code